Work sample test and structured interview for {role_name}

After shortlisting, assess candidates' skills with a work sample task, followed by an assessment and thorough evaluation.

How to structure the interview to assess skills and cultural fit for {role_name}

Work sample test (Home assignment)

Recruitment Bullet

Assess the candidate’s practical skills by assigning a real-world task similar to the work they would do if hired.

  • Title: Improve the Checkout Experience of an E-commerce App
  • Objective: Evaluate the candidate’s ability to understand user pain points, prioritize solutions, and define a product approach.
  • Requirements: The candidate must submit:
    • A short problem statement
    • Two user personas
    • A prioritized list of 3 features or improvements
    • Simple mockups or flow (optional)
    • Success metrics (how improvement will be measured)
  • Time Frame: 3 to 5 hours of work, submitted within 3 calendar days.

Questions based on home assignment : 

Recruitment Bullet

Once done with work sample test evaluate the candidate’s technical proficiency based on the work sample task.

Technical questions

Recruitment Bullet

Duration : 10 minutes/question

  1. Question: How would you prioritize the product improvements you suggested?
    1. Expected Answer: Mentions a framework such as RICE, MoSCoW, or value vs effort analysis.
    2. Sample Answer: “I used the RICE framework to evaluate each feature. The guest checkout scored highest because it impacts conversion and has relatively low effort.”

  2. Question: What metrics would you use to measure success
    1. Expected Answer: Mentions measurable product KPIs such as conversion rate, checkout drop-off rate, time-to-checkout, or successful order completion.
    2. Sample Answer: “The primary metric is checkout conversion rate. Secondary metrics include cart abandonment reduction and time taken to complete checkout.”

  3. Question: How did you identify the user pain points?
    1. Expected Answer: References data, user research, competitor benchmarking, or usability findings.
    2. Sample Answer:“I reviewed common industry reports and patterns. Checkout friction usually comes from mandatory account creation and unclear fees, so I used those insights.”

Behavioral questions

Recruitment Bullet

Duration : 10 minutes/question

  1. Question:Tell me about a time you had conflicting priorities and how you managed them.
    1. Expected Answer: Demonstrates prioritization using a framework, stakeholder alignment, and clear communication.
    2. Sample Answer: “When engineering bandwidth was limited, I worked with the tech lead to evaluate effort and impact and communicated trade-offs with stakeholders so everyone aligned on the decision.”

  2. Question: Describe a situation where your idea was challenged. What did you do?
    1. Expected Answer: Shows openness, collaboration, data-driven reasoning, and flexibility.
    2. Sample Answer:“I listened to the feedback and gathered additional user and performance data. Once shared, the team agreed to test my approach as an A/B experiment.”

  3. Question: How do you handle disagreement between teams like engineering and design
    1. Expected Answer: Looks for conflict resolution, empathy, and decision-making frameworks
    2. Sample Answer: “I ensure both teams explain their reasoning, then align the discussion toward user outcomes and business goals. The final call depends on measurable success criteria.”

How to evaluate and compare candidates after interviews?

After interviews, it's important to evaluate and compare candidates based on a set of predefined criteria.Use scorecard to evaluate each candidate.

Recruitment Bullet

Sample scorecard based on pre-defined criteria. Here’s an example:

Evaluation Criteria What to Look For Rating (1-5) Comments
Understanding of the Problem Did the candidate clearly understand the task, user pain points, and product context?
Prioritization and Decision-Making Did they use a framework or logical reasoning to prioritize features or solutions?
Product Thinking and Strategy Did they demonstrate strong user-centric thinking and clear product outcomes?

"Standardize interviews" – Use our customizable scorecard templates

What criteria should be used to make the final hiring decision?

Final decisions should be based on the candidate's overall evaluation score, with a focus on important qualifications. Prioritize technical skills above everything else for a {role_name}, but do not forget about communication and cultural fit.

Recruitment Bullet

How to communicate the decision to candidates

Sample offer letter for {role_name}

Subject: Offer of Employment –  Product Manager Position

Hi {name},

Thank you for going through our selection process. We are pleased to offer you the position of Product Manager. Your experience in product strategy and user-centered thinking makes you a great fit for our team.

We will share the formal offer with compensation, benefits, and onboarding details shortly.
Please reply confirming acceptance or any questions you may have.

Looking forward to having you on the team.

Best regards,
{Recruiter Name}

Sample rejection letter for {role_name}

Subject: Update on Your  Product Manager Application

Hi {name},

Thank you for your time and effort during the interview process. At this time, we have decided to move forward with another candidate.

We genuinely appreciate your interest and encourage you to apply for future opportunities that match your profile.

Wishing you the best in your career journey.

Best regards,
{Recruiter Name}